How to Use a Debt Restructuring Simulation to Teach Financial Turnaround Strategies

By: Gerhard Wörtche Published On: 18th February 2025

1. TLDR

Debt restructuring simulations offer a powerful, hands-on way to teach financial turnaround strategies. In this article, we’ll guide you through the essentials of using these simulations effectively - helping your students gain real-world crisis management skills. We’ll discuss how to select the right simulation, how to schedule it for maximum impact, and the preparation needed to ensure both you and your students get the most out of the experience.

2. Choose the Most Appropriate Debt Restructuring Simulation for Your Course

Selecting the right debt restructuring simulation is a critical first step. You need something that goes beyond basic textbook theory and offers an immersive, practical experience. It should challenge students to navigate the complexities of financial distress, stakeholder management, and crisis resolution.

We know that financial simulations aren’t all created equal. Some are more about theory than practice. Others, while engaging, may not reflect the nuances of real-world financial distress. So, how do you choose the right one?

Start by asking yourself a few key questions:

• Does it reflect real-world complexities? Ensure that the simulation incorporates realistic financial scenarios - everything from analyzing distressed financial statements to assessing debt obligations.
• Does it offer decision-making autonomy? Students should be able to take on roles within a distressed company and make strategic decisions, like renegotiating debt or considering asset divestiture.
• Does it promote teamwork? A solid debt restructuring simulation encourages collaboration, allowing students to develop their critical thinking and interpersonal skills.
• Is it immersive? The most effective simulations allow participants to feel the pressure and urgency of managing a distressed company, making it a dynamic learning environment.

Our own simulations are designed with these considerations in mind. They draw on insights from our early days at Morgan Stanley, where we created a tool to immerse participants in key financial transactions. Over time, we refined this tool into a high-quality, gamified simulation that’s used by financial institutions globally. The goal was never just to simulate transactions; it was about creating a space where participants could experience the motivations of all involved parties in a restructuring process.

The result? A series of simulations that give students a comprehensive understanding of turnaround strategies in ways traditional coursework can’t.

3. Schedule the Simulation’s Use Wisely

Timing matters. A debt restructuring simulation is a significant undertaking, and how you integrate it into your course will directly impact how well your students grasp the material.

First, consider when students are most likely to benefit from this experience. This type of simulation is most effective once students have a solid understanding of basic financial principles. The best time to introduce it is after they’ve explored topics like financial statements, debt instruments, and the fundamentals of corporate finance.

Here’s a suggestion for structuring the timeline:

1. Pre-Simulation Preparation: Before the simulation, ensure that students have a foundation in core concepts like balance sheets, income statements, and cash flow analysis. You could have them review these concepts in small group discussions or through short case studies.
2. Simulation Execution: During the simulation, encourage students to work in teams to simulate the restructuring process, ensuring they actively engage with both the financial details and strategic decision-making.
3. Post-Simulation Debrief: After the simulation ends, provide a structured debrief session to discuss the outcomes. What went well? What didn’t? Which decisions could have been improved with more data or insight?

The simulation itself can be spread over multiple sessions to give students the time and mental space they need to absorb the complexities of a financial turnaround. However, it’s important not to overload them - too many simulations too quickly will dilute their learning experience.

In our experience, these simulations yield the best results when they’re spaced out enough to give students time for reflection, but not so far apart that they lose the connection between theory and practice.

By carefully timing the simulation, you set your students up for success and ensure the learning experience is as impactful as possible.

4. Prepare Yourself and Your Students for this Debt Restructuring Simulation

Before diving into a debt restructuring simulation, proper preparation is key - for both you and your students.

For You: Be Ready to Guide, Not Just Teach

As the instructor, your role in the simulation is not just to present information, but to facilitate. This means you need to have a deep understanding of the financial concepts involved and a clear idea of how to guide students through the simulation process.

Here’s how to prepare:

• Familiarize Yourself with the Simulation: Even if you've used simulations before, each one is different. Take the time to walk through the simulation yourself. Familiarize yourself with the key decisions students will face, the flow of the game, and the financial reports they will need to analyze.
• Know the Learning Objectives: Ensure you have clear, actionable learning goals for the simulation. These might include things like understanding the complexities of debt negotiation, prioritizing stakeholder interests, or applying operational improvements in distressed scenarios.
• Prepare for Troubleshooting: While simulations are highly effective, they don’t always go smoothly. There will likely be moments when students struggle to understand the financials or make decisions that seem to "fail." Be prepared to step in with guidance, helping them troubleshoot and view mistakes as learning opportunities.

For Your Students: Set Expectations Early

Your students are experts in their own right. They understand finance, but they might not have experience in crisis management or corporate turnarounds. This simulation will push them outside their comfort zones, and it’s important they’re prepared.

Here’s how to ensure they’re set up for success:

• Introduce the Concepts Early: Make sure students understand the key principles of debt restructuring before starting. Hold a session on the basics of distressed assets, debt renegotiation, and turnaround strategies.
• Clarify the Roles: Each student in the simulation will likely take on a specific role (e.g., CFO, restructuring advisor, banker). Clarify what is expected of them, ensuring they know how their role fits into the larger strategic puzzle.
• Encourage Teamwork: This isn’t a solo mission. Ensure students understand that success comes from collaborating, pooling knowledge, and learning from their peers. Foster a culture of teamwork where students feel empowered to make decisions together and challenge each other's ideas.
• Provide a Clear Brief: Give students a comprehensive outline of what they can expect during the simulation. Detail the financial scenarios they’ll be dealing with, the deadlines they’ll face, and the outcomes they should aim for. Setting clear expectations helps them approach the simulation with confidence.

Preparing your students in this way helps them engage more deeply in the process and ensures they’re ready to take full advantage of the learning experience.

5. Enjoy the Rewards

Once the simulation is underway, you’ll start to see the real rewards. Students will begin to apply their theoretical knowledge in practical ways, developing skills they can use in real-world financial turnaround situations.

For Students: Real-World, Actionable Learning

The hands-on nature of debt restructuring simulations is one of their greatest strengths. Unlike textbook exercises, this experience allows students to practice the real-time decision-making that’s central to financial recovery and crisis management.

The rewards for students include:

• Critical Thinking: They’ll develop the ability to think critically and quickly under pressure - skills essential for any finance professional.
• Stakeholder Management: Through their roles, students will learn to balance competing interests, whether it’s shareholders, creditors, or employees. This multi-dimensional approach helps them see the broader implications of every decision.
• Tangible Skills: The experience will give students practical skills that can directly translate into their future careers. These aren’t just theoretical exercises - they’re decisions with real financial consequences.

For You: Strengthen Your Teaching Impact

As an instructor, the rewards extend beyond your students' growth. When you see them navigate a crisis, restructure debt, and ultimately come to a resolution, you’ll know that you’ve made a lasting impact.

• Student Engagement: Simulations naturally lead to higher engagement. Students invest more when they’re emotionally and intellectually involved in solving a problem. This investment leads to better learning outcomes.
• Insights for Future Improvements: Every simulation provides valuable feedback, helping you refine your teaching methods. You’ll be able to identify where students struggled and where they excelled, giving you the information you need to improve the simulation and your own approach for next time.
• Professional Satisfaction: There’s a certain satisfaction in knowing you’ve helped develop the next generation of financial professionals. By offering a truly immersive learning experience, you’re equipping your students with the tools to succeed in complex financial environments.

Ultimately, the rewards for both you and your students go far beyond the immediate simulation. This hands-on experience nurtures the skills, critical thinking, and strategic mindset needed to manage real-world financial turnarounds successfully.

6. Troubleshooting Thoughts

Even with meticulous preparation, things won’t always go according to plan. It’s inevitable that your students will encounter challenges during the debt restructuring simulation. But rather than seeing these moments as setbacks, they should be viewed as opportunities for deeper learning.

Here are some troubleshooting tips to help you guide your students through the rough patches:

Common Student Struggles

• Difficulty Analyzing Financial Data: Some students may struggle with the depth of financial analysis required. The financials in the simulation can be complex, and some students may not have had much practical experience with such detailed reports.
  • Solution: Offer clear instructions on how to break down financial statements, focusing on key metrics like liquidity, profitability, and solvency. Encourage students to collaborate on this and break the problem into smaller parts.
• Overwhelmed by Stakeholder Interests: Managing conflicting stakeholder interests is one of the most complex aspects of debt restructuring. Students may find it difficult to balance the needs of creditors, employees, and shareholders.
  • Solution: Remind students that prioritizing is key. They can’t please everyone, but they can aim for a solution that ensures the long-term health of the company. Encourage them to weigh the consequences of each decision on all parties involved and consider how their strategies impact each group.
• Decision Paralysis: In simulations, students may feel overwhelmed by the sheer number of choices and the complexity of their decisions.
  • Solution: Encourage your students to embrace the idea that not every decision needs to be perfect. A timely, reasonable decision can often be better than overthinking and delaying action. Reassure them that real-world decision-making in turnaround situations often involves making imperfect choices with the information at hand.

Be There to Support

Troubleshooting isn’t just about solving problems - it’s also about providing emotional support. Students will need to feel that they can trust you to guide them through difficult moments.

By maintaining a calm and steady presence, you’ll show them how to stay composed under pressure - just like they’ll need to do when they’re in real-world financial roles.

7. The Good You’ll Do for Your Business School

By integrating debt restructuring simulations into your curriculum, you’ll be doing much more than enhancing the academic experience for your students. You’ll also be elevating your business school’s standing in the global academic and professional community.

Enhance Your Reputation as a Cutting-Edge Educator

Your use of innovative teaching methods - such as gamified simulations - shows that your school is ahead of the curve. By giving students the chance to engage with realistic, immersive financial simulations, you’re positioning your institution as one that delivers top-tier financial education.

• Attract Talent: Students - especially those pursuing finance and business degrees - are drawn to programs that offer hands-on learning experiences. Your commitment to experiential education will help you attract top talent.
• Collaborate with Industry: Schools that use advanced simulations are often more likely to build relationships with corporations and financial institutions. By demonstrating that your students are equipped to tackle real-world financial problems, you increase your chances of forging valuable industry partnerships.

Foster Long-Term Career Success

Your use of these simulations will also enhance your alumni’s career prospects. When your graduates step into the professional world, they’ll be equipped with practical skills that set them apart in a competitive job market.

They’ll not only understand the theory behind debt restructuring and financial turnarounds - they’ll also know how to apply these concepts effectively in real-world situations. This gives them a substantial edge when it comes to interviews, promotions, or career transitions.

Furthermore, you’re helping to build a network of graduates who can speak to the value of their education. When alumni excel in the field, it reflects positively on your institution, creating a virtuous cycle that benefits current and future students.

8. Conclusion

Using Finsimco’s Debt Restructuring Simulation to teach financial turnaround strategies provides an invaluable, hands-on learning experience for your students. By carefully selecting the right simulation, preparing both yourself and your students, and troubleshooting as needed, you’ll help your students gain practical, real-world experience that will last a lifetime.

The rewards of incorporating simulations into your curriculum are undeniable. Not only do they foster critical thinking and teamwork in your students, but they also help strengthen your business school’s reputation, while equipping your graduates with the skills they need to thrive in the real world.

By embracing simulations as a teaching tool, you’re providing your students with more than just a classroom exercise. You’re preparing them for the complex, nuanced world of financial turnarounds - giving them the skills to lead and succeed in even the most challenging situations.